Choosing a simulation assessment tool: A comparative analysis in Bihar, India

HILARY SPINDLER (1) , JULIA RANEY (2) , SUSANNA COHEN (3) , RAKESH GHOSH (4) , JESSICA DYER (5) , AMELIA CHRISTMAS (6) , MANJU SIJU (7) , RENU SHARMA (8) , ROHIT SRIVASTAVA (9) , ARITRA DAS (10) , ABOLI GORE (11) , PRAMOD SAH (12) , SUNIL SONTHALIA (13) , TANMAY MAHAPATRA (14) , DILYS WALKER (15)
(1)
(2) School of Medicine, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, United States of America , United States
(3) College of Nursing, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, United States of America , United States
(4) Institute for Global Health Sciences, University of California, San Francisco, California, United States of America , United States
(5) Pronto International, Seattle, Washington, United States of America , United States
(6) Pronto International, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(7) Pronto International, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(8) Pronto International, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(9) Pronto International, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(10) CARE India Solutions for Sustainable Development, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(11) CARE India Solutions for Sustainable Development, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(12) CARE India Solutions for Sustainable Development, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(13) CARE India Solutions for Sustainable Development, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(14) CARE India Solutions for Sustainable Development, Patna, Bihar, India , India
(15) Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, University of California San Francisco, California, United States of America , United States

Abstract

BACKGROUND

To explore whether clinical, teamwork, and interpersonal skills of nurses could be monitored inexpensively at scale, we compared two simulation measurement tools at 160 primary health care facilities in Bihar, India. The aim was to determine if the less expensive, less resource-intensive real-time assessment tool (RTAT) could be used in place of the more expensive, more resource-intensive video coding tool.


METHODS

Embedded in a large-scale ongoing nurse mentoring program “AMANAT”, we conducted a cross-sectional study comparing the measurement tools to assess clinical performance in normal and emergency obstetrical and neonatal simulations. The RTAT consisted of a series of seven global questions related to clinical identification, management, use of evidence-based practices, communication and teamwork. We also analysed the simulations using a video coding tool, which included 80 clinical, teamwork and communication indicators. We calculated the means and standard errors for each indicator using both tools. We calculated the Cohen’s kappa coefficient to determine the level of agreement between the two tools.


RESULTS

We analysed paired data from the two tools for 222 simulations in three types of scenarios: normal spontaneous vaginal deliveries, neonatal resuscitations and post-partum haemorrhages. The mean scores on the RTAT were generally higher than those on the video coding tool. The kappa coefficients for all indicators indicated no agreement between the two tools.


CONCLUSION

RTAT performed poorly against the video coding tool to measure the clinical skills of nurses in simulated normal and complicated births at primary health care facilities in Bihar.

Full text article

Generated from XML file

Authors

HILARY SPINDLER
hilary.spindler@ucsf.edu (Primary Contact)
JULIA RANEY
SUSANNA COHEN
RAKESH GHOSH
JESSICA DYER
AMELIA CHRISTMAS
MANJU SIJU
RENU SHARMA
ROHIT SRIVASTAVA
ARITRA DAS
ABOLI GORE
PRAMOD SAH
SUNIL SONTHALIA
TANMAY MAHAPATRA
DILYS WALKER
SPINDLER, H., RANEY, J., COHEN, S., GHOSH, R., DYER, J., CHRISTMAS, A., SIJU, M., SHARMA, R., SRIVASTAVA, R., DAS, A., GORE, A., SAH, P., SONTHALIA, S., MAHAPATRA, T., & WALKER, D. (2018). Choosing a simulation assessment tool:: A comparative analysis in Bihar, India. Eajahme, 2(2). https://doi.org/10.58498/eajahme.v1i1.16
Copyright and license info is not available

Article Details

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.

Does teamwork and communication improve with simulation training? An evaluation of simulation training videos in Bihar, India

JESSICA D DYER, MELISSA C MORGAN, SUSANNA R COHEN, RAKESH GHOSH, JULIA RANEY, HILARY SPINDLER,...
Abstract View : 166
Download :82